There are a few things you can safely assume about the Duggar family. They will have a new scandal once every few years, they still believe in homeschooling with a program heavily rooted in religion above all else, and they support Donald Trump. That last bit also extends to other family members, because many are pretty sure that cousin Amy Duggar also supports Trump, given things she has said in the past.

However, after she shared the now-infamous AI photo of Trump as Jesus that he originally shared on Truth Social in her Instagram Stories, there’s some confusion about what the “rebel Duggar” actually believes. A Reddit post dedicated to what she meant or didn’t mean with her post has people trying to figure out Amy all over again.

Amy Duggar’s post about AI Trump Jesus is a head scratcher.

Amy shared Trump’s AI photo in her Instagram Stories and wrote along with it, “Every other god is an idol.” The picture, in case anyone needs a refresher, depicts Trump as Jesus as he stands over the hospital bed of a sick man. His hand is stretched out over the man and what can only be described as a healing light is coming from Trump’s hand to presumably heal the man.

There are also veterans, the Statue of Liberty, a waving American flag, and soaring eagles in the image. We aren’t even going to get into how much water was wasted in giving AI a prompt for this particular picture. But when Amy shared it, along with her simple sentence, it left some wondering if the post was meant to praise Trump or condemn him, especially given the general Duggar stance on supporting Trump as the president.

“Explain like I’m Joy, please. Isn’t she kind of criticizing Trump here?” Someone commented on Reddit, in reference to Joy-Anna Duggar.

Another user responded to them with, “She’s calling him out. For false idolatry.”

A Redditor also pointed out in the thread, “Yes they’re all mad he pretended to be Jesus but they’re totally cool with his name being in the Epstein files 10 million times.”

Another confused person wrote, “I feel dumb, but is she supporting Trump here or calling him an idol? Or saying every God outside of Trump is an idol?”

It’s a fair question, since it isn’t totally clear right away what Amy is trying to say.

Luckily, another user replied to that person: “No she’s saying Trump acting like a god is a false idol. She’s criticizing him. Weird that this is the one thing his Christian supporters seem to have a problem with.”

She later posted on Instagram about the Trump Jesus photo in more detail

Maybe Amy saw the confusion on Reddit, or people reached out to her to ask what the heck she was getting at with her Instagram Stories. But, after she made that post in her Stories, which expired after some time, Amy posted the same image on Instagram and wrote a list in the caption of everything she finds “awful” and offensive.

“First of all, putting Donald Trump in the place of Jesus is not just ‘a little off’,” she wrote in the caption. “It is wildly, deeply, spiritually wrong. It is not a joke. It’s 100% blasphemy.”

She also wrote, “Jesus calls us to think, to test spirits, to seek truth. Not to blindly follow a political figure like they’re our savior.” Amy added later in the caption, “When we stop being careful with spiritual language, we start putting people in places only God should be. Trump is not all knowing, he cannot hear your prayers. This is idolatry. There is only one ‘light of the world,’ and it’s Jesus Christ.”

She once posted in support of Trump as the president.

To be fair, some of the confusion came with Amy’s seemingly former stance on Trump. When he was elected into office in 2016, Amy posted about it on X (formerly Twitter). At the time, she wrote, “I love that Trump mentioned the veterans. I love that he thanked God for his Presidency, I loved that our new President loves this country!”

That image of the president might have changed since then, and in light of Trump’s truly bonkers second term in office. But people have the tendency to, well, not forget, when it comes to politics and problematic ideas that were put out into the ether. And honestly, most of the Duggars support Trump in every other aspect. In 2019, Justin Duggar reportedly mowed ‘TRUMP 2020’ into the grass on the Duggar family’s front lawn in Tontitown, Ark. So yeah, they’re pretty deep in it, even if Amy might not be anymore.